The first Americans have much to teach us.
نویسندگان
چکیده
In this month_s issue of the Journal, Whitbeck et al. report that indigenous adolescents living on the northwest border of the United States experienced a striking increase in mental disorders between 10 and 12 and 13 and 15 years of age. The rates in this population were accounted for by increases in conduct disorder and substance use disorders. According to the authors, the study participants_ rates for these disorders were two to four times the rates of adolescents in general population studies and similar to lifetime prevalence rates for adults. The article by Whitbeck et al. sounds the alarm on a mental health crisis for indigenous youths in rural reservation communities. However, two caveats must be noted. First, the Indian Health Service consistently reports large regional differences in all health trends across tribes, so caution must be exercised before generalizing these findings to all Native American youths. Second, as Whitbeck et al. have acknowledged, mental health measures have not been well tested with Native American youngsters, and cultural differences may produce measurement biases. Nonetheless, it is essential to counter those caveats with other evidence that supports the reality of a mental health crisis for Native American youths. First, the environmental and developmental risks that Whitbeck et al. describe for childhood behavior problems and substance use disorders are common in rural indigenous populations across the United States and the world. Second, although mental health measures used in the study may lack some degree of cultural sensitivity, measurement biases would likely result in underreporting in general, especially substance use disorders and internalizing disorders. Disruptive behavior, which is more overt, may be less subject to reporting bias, but may still be underreported in indigenous communities. Third, the findings of Whitbeck and colleagues are harbingers of the painful truth that Native American youths as they move through adolescence and into young adulthood (ages 15Y24) shoulder an eightfold greater rate of alcohol-related deaths and twofold or higher rates for suicide, motor vehicle accidents, and all injury-related deaths. Coming to grips with the pivotal association of early disruptive behavior and substance use disorders with these tragic statistics is critical to finding the solution to high rates of mental health morbidity and mortality in Native American youths. Thus, the article by Whitbeck et al. begs the question: how do we prioritize scarce research dollars and clinical resources for Indian country to address the mental health crisis and resulting mortality of this generation of adolescents and young adults? Is more research needed to rediscover the causal pathways from cultural oppression and economic and psychosocial adversity to poor mental and behavioral outcomes for indigenous children? We would argue no. Rather, we propose that the field accept that a constellation of historical, demographic, and sociological factors have precipitated a mental health crisis for Native American youths and move on to seek approaches to deploy cost-effective, evidence-based solutions that reflect indigenous cultural strengths and community will. To begin to address these problems, we would ask what the existing research tells us about the antecedents of early disruptive behavior and substance use. What are critical time points for intervention and targets for prevention? A large body of research points to early childhood as the critical stage for intervention and family-based approaches, specifically early parenting training, as a key strategy for the prevention of children_s future disruptive behavior problems and substance use disorders. Parent training and family-based approaches have a natural cultural fit within pan-Native American world views. There are numerous examples of how Native Americans traditions favor Bfamily[ above any other domain as the nexus of strength for individuals. Native Americans often introduce themselves by name and clan, underscoring the link between personal identity and family lineage. Many healing traditions and puberty ceremonies involve extended family members who represent stabilizing and restorative forces. In addition, E D I T O R I A L
منابع مشابه
Content Analysis of Elementary Science Books by Using Soft Educational Technology to Teach Environmental Issues in Iran and Russia
Hard educational technologies received more attention today while soft educational technology has been considered as one of the keys and effective technologies in teaching and learning. The main purpose of this study was to investigate the use of soft educational technologies in teaching environmental issues in the first to the third grade of elementary science textbooks of Iran and Russia. Thi...
متن کاملبررسی خودشیفتگی ناسالم در نمونه ای از دانشجویان ایرانی و آمریکایی
According to the continuum hypothesis, narcissism is a personality construct relevant to a dimension of psychological functioning that ranges from pathological narcissism, to healthy narcissism, and finally to self-esteem. This possibility first appeared in studies examining factors from the Narcissistic Personality Inventory (NPI) in American samples. Unpublished previous studies have revealed...
متن کاملWhy We Want Everyone to Be Like Us
We Americans believe that there is basically one rational way to live: ours. There is one legitimate path of development, which leads toward democracy, transparency, and a competitive market system. Our dealings with the rest of the world are based on this assumption. We reinforce the point by dispatching economists, foreign aid workers, and religious missionaries to teach the world how to live...
متن کاملSocial Determinants of Polypharmacy in First Generation Mexican Immigrants in the United States
Introduction: Socioeconomic status (SES) indicators are among the main social determinants of health and illness. Less, however, is known about the role of SES in the epidemiology of polypharmacy in immigrant Latino Americans living in the United States. This research studied the association between three SES indicators, education, income, and employment, and polypharmacy in ol...
متن کاملAnalysis of the photo–damaging performance of persian “orosi” in carpeted and non–carpeted spaces
Traditional building technologies have much to teach us about how to design regionally appropriate structures. The Orosi is one of these useful technologies, which has been used for many centuries in order to control the harsh sunlight in Iran. This architectural element was rather important because the intensive solar radiation could easily damage valuable carpets used in most spaces in Persia...
متن کاملPostgraduate education for pediatricians.
Thank you very much for inviting me to start off the discussions today on post-graduate medical education. Historically post-graduate education has always been grounded in the perception of the specific health care needs of patients. Therefore, I'm first going to address some of the more important health care needs of children, emphasizing the unmet needs which future pediatricians must be prep...
متن کاملذخیره در منابع من
با ذخیره ی این منبع در منابع من، دسترسی به آن را برای استفاده های بعدی آسان تر کنید
عنوان ژورنال:
- Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
دوره 47 8 شماره
صفحات -
تاریخ انتشار 2008